2.1
Qubahan Academic Journal (QAJ) operates a double-anonymous (double-blind) peer review system. Under this model, reviewers do not receive the identities of the authors, and authors do not receive the identities of the reviewers during the peer review process.
The journal applies this model to scholarly manuscripts submitted for publication, including original research articles, review articles, and research letters, where applicable.
Editors and authorized editorial staff may access author identities for manuscript administration, reviewer selection, ethical oversight, and editorial decision-making.
QAJ is committed to independent evaluation, academic integrity, confidentiality, fairness, and transparency in editorial decision-making.
Following submission, each manuscript undergoes an initial editorial screening by the Editor-in-Chief or an assigned handling editor.
The screening evaluates:
Relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
Originality and scholarly contribution.
Suitability of the research design and methodology.
Quality and clarity of the manuscript.
Compliance with submission requirements.
Compliance with research and publication ethics.
Potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, or other research-integrity concerns.
Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements may be rejected without external peer review. Authors will receive an editorial notification explaining the decision.
Authors must submit a manuscript prepared for anonymous review.
The anonymized manuscript must not contain author names, institutional affiliations, email addresses, acknowledgments identifying the authors, or other information that would directly disclose authorship.
Author identification and relevant declarations should be provided separately where required by the submission system.
Self-citations should be presented in a neutral manner that does not unnecessarily identify the author.
Editors are responsible for checking whether identifying information has been adequately removed before assigning a manuscript for external review.
If a reviewer inadvertently discovers an author's identity, the reviewer must notify the handling editor and must continue to maintain confidentiality.
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are assigned to at least two independent external reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript.
Reviewers are selected on the basis of their academic qualifications, research expertise, publication experience, independence, and ability to provide an objective assessment.
Reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest before accepting an invitation.
Editors must avoid appointing reviewers where relationships or competing interests could compromise impartiality.
Additional reviewers may be appointed when necessary, including when reports provide insufficient information or substantially conflicting recommendations.
Reviewers are requested to evaluate manuscripts according to the following criteria:
Originality and contribution to existing knowledge.
Relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
Appropriateness and rigor of the research methodology.
Validity and reliability of the findings.
Adequacy of data analysis and interpretation.
Quality, relevance, and accuracy of references.
Clarity, organization, and scholarly presentation.
Compliance with applicable research ethics.
Support for conclusions from the presented evidence.
Reviewers must provide constructive, evidence-based feedback and avoid personal criticism.
Reviewers may recommend one of the following outcomes:
Accept.
Minor revision.
Major revision.
Reject.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final editorial decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or a duly authorized handling editor.
Where reviewer recommendations differ, the editor may obtain an additional independent review or provide a documented editorial assessment.
Authors invited to revise their manuscripts must provide a revised version and a point-by-point response to reviewer comments.
Minor revisions may be assessed by the handling editor. Major revisions may be returned to the original reviewers or evaluated by additional reviewers when appropriate.
Additional review rounds may be conducted when necessary to determine whether the manuscript meets the journal's scholarly and ethical requirements.
An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.
The final decision is based on the manuscript's academic merit, the reviewers' assessments, the authors' responses, the journal's editorial policies, and any relevant ethical considerations.
Acceptance decisions must not be influenced by article processing charges, financial considerations, personal relationships, institutional affiliation, or the nationality of the authors.
The journal communicates decisions and relevant reviewer comments to the corresponding author through the editorial management system.
Editors and reviewers must treat submitted manuscripts, associated data, reviewer reports, and editorial correspondence as confidential.
Reviewers must not share manuscripts with third parties without prior editorial authorization.
Unpublished information obtained during peer review must not be used for personal research or advantage without appropriate authorization.
Reviewers and editors must disclose any financial, academic, personal, institutional, or professional interests that could influence their evaluation of a manuscript.
Individuals with conflicts that compromise impartiality must withdraw from handling or reviewing the affected manuscript.
Reviewers must:
Accept assignments only when they possess appropriate subject expertise.
Inform the editor promptly if unable to complete the review.
Evaluate submissions objectively and respectfully.
Maintain the confidentiality of the review process.
Report suspected plagiarism, manipulation, fabrication, or ethical misconduct.
Provide clear and constructive recommendations supported by evidence.
QAJ maintains editorial independence in manuscript evaluation and publication decisions.
Final decisions are determined by scholarly merit, methodological quality, ethical compliance, and relevance to the journal's stated aims and scope.
QAJ publicly describes its peer review procedures and applies its published editorial policies consistently.
The journal does not guarantee acceptance, and the number of review rounds may vary depending on the complexity and quality of each submission.
The identities of anonymous reviewers are protected in accordance with the journal's double-anonymous peer review policy.
Publisher Address : No. 5, Yana Road st, KRO, Duhok city, Kurdistan-Region, Iraq
Email: support@qubahan.com
![]() |
|||||
|
|||||